Intelligent Design, the best explanation of Origins

This is my personal virtual library, where i collect information, which leads in my view to Intelligent Design as the best explanation of the origin of the physical Universe, life, and biodiversity


You are not connected. Please login or register

Intelligent Design, the best explanation of Origins » Molecular biology of the cell » What determines cell size?

What determines cell size?

Go down  Message [Page 1 of 1]

1What determines cell size? Empty What determines cell size? on Wed Oct 17, 2018 7:02 am

Admin


Admin
What determines cell size?

Why do cells care how big or small they are? One reason cell size matters is that the basic processes of cell physiology, such as flux across membranes, are by their nature dependent on cell size. As a result, changes in cell volume or surface area will have profound effects on metabolic flux, biosynthetic capacity, and nutrient exchange. A second reason is that the basic machinery of cell division in eukaryotes relies on microtubules, both to form the mitotic spindle and position it properly relative to the cortex. Because of the dynamic properties of microtubules, they are able to probe a limited range of lengths, and if cells get too big or too small, the mitotic apparatus may have difficulty working. Very small cells could not form a proper spindle, and very large cells could not coordinate their divisions during cleavage. 1

In both animals and plants, cells must fit together like puzzle pieces to form tissues and organs, and that means that a cell has to have a size appropriate to its position within the overall tissue.

Question: What would and could drive unguided, non-intelligent biochemical reactions the creation of Cells, that fit together like a puzzle? Given that cell size is important, would not a cell program be required that presets and controls how big it supposedly has to become?  In terms of 'design principles' for a size control system, the most fundamental question is whether cells need to be preprogrammed to grow the right size and to control development. Would that not indicate that a model is most plausible where cell mass grow is preestablished at some rate determined by molecular information and governed by preestablished signal and communication systems? Indeed, it is, as we will see:  

Cells measure their own size and regulate the timing of cell division accordingly.

To do so and "know" when they reached their right size, that "knowledge" must be preestablished. Amazingly, they do so by reading out intracellular gradients. Regulation of cell size is the combined result of several mechanisms operating in parallel !!  

It further amazes and surprises that the volume of normally tiny cells can differ by as much as 106- to 108-fold, from the tiniest 0.2 μm cells of the Pelagibacter clade that fills the oceans to the monstrous genera Thiomargarita and Epulopiscium in which some species measure over 600 to 700 μm in length or diameter and are visible to the naked eye !!

Cells divide at some constant frequency set by the cell cycle clock.

A central clock runs the cell division cycle
Each time a cell divides, it replicates its DNA once, then separates the two copies from each other and splits into two daughter cells. The event is intricately coordinated and was long known to be under the influence of cyclins—an aptly named group of proteins whose levels go up and down as the cell traverses through the different phases of its division cycle. 2

Cyclin is a family of proteins that control the progression of cells through the cell cycle by activating cyclin-dependent kinase (Cdk) enzymes  3  They are like a central clock in a factory that orients each machine and production line when to do its jobs.

Throughout cell-cycle progression, the expression of multiple transcripts oscillate and are under the centralized control of the CDK-APC/C proteins. Most or all cell-cycle events such as periodic DNA replication, nuclear division, and cytokinesis are directly driven from the CDK-APC/C “clock”. CDK-APC/C control is strongly dominant. 6

Question: Has the control of the progression of the Cell Cycle not need to be preestablished ? 

Cells use various cell-cycle checkpoints. Cell cycle checkpoints are control mechanisms in eukaryotic cells which ensure proper division of the cell. Each checkpoint serves as a potential point along the cell cycle, during which the conditions of the cell are assessed, with progression through the various phases of the cell cycle occurring when favorable conditions are met. 4  The checkpoint pathways can be thought of as the cell’s surveillance systems that function to arrest cell cycle progression in response to detected problems in cell division or chromosome replication. Checkpoint pathways ensure that DNA replication does not commence before all of the components necessary for its completion have been produced. Checkpoint pathways are essential for an organism’s viability. Although a cell can complete its cycle successfully without them, their absence results in infidelity of chromosome transmission and a greatly raised susceptibility to DNA-damaging agents. The consequence of checkpoint pathway inactivation is genome instability, which inevitably leads to cancer 5

Everything must happen in a particular order to make sure the finished product comes out properly. First the various cellular structures must be duplicated, then DNA must be copied and acquire the appropriate scaffolding, and only then can the cell finally split in two. These events must happen in a coordinated manner, each in its designated time.

Question: Had this designation not to be preprogrammed in advance? And the Cell Cycle checkpoints in place? In fact, in below article, I list 20 Essential Cell-Cycle Regulators:

Reproduction is essential for the survival of all living things and requires an irreducibly complex regulation process
http://reasonandscience.catsboard.com/t2109-the-cell-cycle#5660

How do Cells "know" what size they should be ?
When considering the intelligence of individual cells, certain things stand out. Cells know exactly where they are and how to travel to far away places through many kinds of terrain with many different techniques. Cells know how to signal back and forth wirelessly to many different types of cells using many different signals. Cells know how to become a particular type of cell and stay that way.  7

There are many aspects to cellular intelligence. Cells understanding its relation to the external environment and world without GPS. Cells know where it should be and how it knows how to travel long distances over complex terrain to exact places.

It is remarkable that a cell can know exactly where it is in a large world of billions of cells. Cells are programmed to make complex calculations and decisions based on its relation to other cells. Immune and blood cells need to know exactly where trauma or infection is located and how to get there. Neurons find very precise locations in the fetus and the adult brains. Growing cells in limbs and organs know exactly how they fit into the shape and where the edge should stop.

Cells use multiple measurements and rules to calculate and adjust for many sources of error in this process. Data comes from diffusible molecules of morphogenic fields, electrical gradients and networks of genes.

Electrical Fields Guiding 3D Shape of Cells and Organs
http://reasonandscience.catsboard.com/t2293-the-recent-groundbreaking-scientific-research-which-explains-the-real-mechanisms-of-biodiversity


They signal to other cells to validate or amplify this information. Cells take measurements and then check with neighbors. Measuring a gradient is difficult with many accuracy problems. Cells use multiple feedback loops, timed measurements, gene regulation, signaling and self-organization with other cells. Each situation has many variables and cells are preprogrammed to be virtual mathematicians to synthesize the information.

To travel to far away places, leukocytes, T cells, and other immune cells use thousands of different factors and many different modes of travel. They change their size for different terrain and situations. They signal back and forth for advice and information from blood cells, neurons, endothelial cells, and immune cells; in each type of bodily organ, the communication is different with a large number of cytokines and chemokines.

Leukocytes navigate the blood vessels by grabbing onto the lining with adhesion molecules, then rolling and tethering. They sneak through the cells into the tissue with many techniques. They, then, respond to positive and negative gradients of all kinds. Each cell can use multiple different kinds of movement and different shapes, triggered by genetic networks operating actin-myosin motors and scaffolding structures. Traveling cells can use their leading edge in different ways and can create swarms of large amount of cells in one particular spot. They navigate the extracellular matrix and other obstructions.

Is the size of a cell based on growth and division, its specific function, or is it regulated ? New research shows that it is influenced by regulation as well as factors of growth and division. Most research is based on the idea that the longer it grows the bigger it will be, but this is not always the case. There are many other factors that affect size and growth. Cells can determine how they increase in size, but it is difficult to study metabolism and the feedback loops involved.

The size of a cell is determined by many factors—synthesis and breakdown, nutrition, environmental factors, protein production and autophagy. In some rapidly diving cells, including bacteria, the complex dynamic of growth and cell division determine some aspects of size. But, also, unique functions and physiology affect it. The type of cell that it is becoming from a stem cell—differentiation to a specific sized cell—also is influenced by multiple factors. Cell division cycles controlled by genetic networks, also, determines size.
There are many intersecting questions

- Best size for the cell type
- Response from environment
- How do cells measure themselves
- How does the cell know it is a different size
- In the cell division process, how do cells change their growth to promote specific size
- How do size changes affect functions
- What is the best size for function
- How do cell sizes cause illness
- How do cell sizes cause aging

Organs Maintain a Particular Sized Cell

Every organ in the body, but particularly the brain, functions accurately because cells maintain a very specific size and shape. A lot is known about how cellular networks increase or decrease their growth, such as using the remarkable intelligent mTOR pathways described in another post.
But, this doesn’t begin to answer the question of how the cell knows how it should fit into a larger vision of many cells working together at specific sizes. It is quite remarkable that in organs, most of the cells are the same size, but different between tissues. Epithelial cells are particularly uniform in shape and size and changes are often a sign of the development of cancer.
Even if we consider signals from other places to all the cells, there should be more variability. This variability is dependent on the way the cell’s divide, the rate of growth or nutrient availability. In order to maintain similarity of size with exactly the same environmental factors, there must be an active regulation. Individual cells must measure their own size and then regulate exactly how small or large they must be.

Cells Measuring Themselves

To determine how large a cell should be it, it must at least alter growth rates and the cell cycles. Different tissues have various abilities to maintain these appropriate sizes—some more effective than others. In many tissues, if cells are the wrong size they don’t perform well.

It is the number of cells, not the size of an individual’s cells that makes one person larger than others. Despite this, organs maintain exact standards of cell size even when people are rapidly growing. During the production of new cells from stem cells, they can become much larger, by orders of magnitude compared with the original stem cell. Bone cells increased their size by more than 10 times when the bone is growing. In the pancreas there are two different cells, right next to each other, where one is two times the size of the other. These examples show that size is highly regulated.

Receptors on the cell’s membrane respond to many signals from the environment that adjust the size of cells—cytokines, growth factors and molecules that signal cell division. Some factors increase cell growth and other stimulates the cell division cycle producing more cells. Some of the same factors function differently for specific cells. Research shows that, although these signals determine the average size of cells, they don’t actually determine the variance of individual cells. This needs the ability of the individual cell to participate in the process. Is there an optimal size for cells to function?

Limiting Variations in Size

When cells are first produced from division, there is a time that they are growing when ultimate size can be determined. One way is to only have cells that have achieved the “correct” size to be able to divide and make more cells. Large cells divide rapidly to cut down the size of the cell in half. Research shows size measurement in the G phase of cell division.
The very complex cell cycle is the process where cells divide and make a new one. It is described as the interphase and then mitosis. The interphase is broken up into parts. The G phase is the “gap” between getting ready and then actually dividing. In G1 cells increase in size and are prepared for the very complex process of copying of the DNA.
The next phase is called S for “synthesis” of DNA. This is when the complex process where copies of the chromosomes are made and divided.

G2 is the time between DNA copying and mitosis when the two cells are pulled apart by a complex microtubule driven process. G2 serves as a checkpoint for size and preparedness. In G2 the cell continues to grow larger. It is here that research shows some regulation of cell size.

In mitosis all cell growth stops and all the energy is put into the orchestration of the breakup into two complete cells. There is another checkpoint in the middle of mitosis (metaphase checkpoint) where everything is checked before it completes the division.

During the cell division cycles, research shows that cells in the S phase have a very variable age, but are very similar in size. In the G phase, cells stay as long as it is needed to become a particular size. There is a process during G phase that large cells become smaller.

Its very difficult to measure how fast an individual cells grows, although there is recent progress with lymphocytes. This study show that the measurement that gates the G phase is consistent with control of rates of cell growth. Slow cells need to grow faster and when they arrive at a specific size and rate they are released. But, other studies show the opposite—the measurement is how large a cell has become.

It is, also, not really known whether cells grow linearly or by orders of magnitude. For the latter, larger cells would be growing faster. This would need another source of regulation. Although mathematical theory related to measurements of cell growth existed for many years, actual accuracy levels have only been achieved recently and, in fact, growth rates are more complex than either. The larger the cell the faster the growth rate, except for very large cells and all are faster than thought in the G phase. Therefore, a strong regulation has to be occurring from somewhere else. This research showed that the larger the cell and the older, the more they divide and make new cells.

Cells Measure Themselves Against an Ideal Size


Skin cells are produced in a very narrow range—between 12 and 14 micrometers. There are gradients inside the cell with less of a particular molecule that simulates cell division in the center of the cell and more at the edges. This gradient seems to trigger cell division at a particular cell size. It prevents the mechanisms of the dividing cell near the edges, keeping the cell above a certain size.
This mechanism has only been, recently, proven for a particular bacteria species. In this situation, the bacteria with a larger initial size divides earlier, whereas one with a smaller initial size divides later. There are transient oscillations, not just in cell size, but also in constitutive gene expression. The cell’s initial size determines how much it will grow before it splits into two.

Another possibility is from another bacteria that measures its own growth rate. A certain rate of protein production is necessary to get out of the G phase to the S phase of cell division. In the beginning of the G phase of activity molecular feedback starts size control. But, later a different mechanism occurs. Small cells take longer in the G phase. Size control is related to a molecule Cln3 in G. But later in G the size determines whether it can leave that phase. Small cells stay longer till they are a specific size and then they proceed to the next phase.
Cln3 senses the need for more protein production and, also, allows the exit from the G phase. However, when there is a very small production of proteins, no Cln3 is made. It is destroyed early and this has a direct relation to the rate of proteins appearing.

Another specific molecule, also, determines the procession to mitosis in another situation. Cln3 operates through affecting the inhibition of transcription factors related to the cell cycle and producing a feedback loop involving Cln2 and Cln1. These start the complex cell division cycle

This mechanism uses a titration of a special molecule against a fixed number of binding sites on the transcription sites. The size of the cell determines this molecule. These molecules somehow trigger the G phase.
Yet another molecule, cyclin E, also senses the production of proteins. It, also, has a differential between transcription and translation which is used as a signal for translation.

Effects of Cell Size

Different physiological situations determine whether there are more cells or larger cells, when more function is required. But, cells have many different functions and so this is hard to determine and there has been little research into this until recently.

Neurons have to be a very precise size to fit in the circuits. Size of neurons greatly influences structure and function in the brain. But, in other organs is it possible that fewer larger cells can do the same job? This would mean the determination of the organ’s uniform cell size is not from the efficiency of its specific functions.
Many different situations alter cell size. In the kidney, the rate of liquid flow affects the size of the cells by triggering cilia sticking out of the cell into the fluid. Lymphocytes change size in response to cytokines. Microglia change shapes and sizes in response to inflammation. (see post)

In pregnancy, the pancreas increases βcell’s size to make more insulin. But, in diabetes, where βcells die, the number of cells increase, not the size of new cells. Liver cells, also, increase size in pregnancy, but after surgery the number increases instead.

The rate of insulin production in βcells is shown to be more connected with cell size than metabolic measures. Metabolism, insulin and protein production are all correlated with βcell size. In another situation, smaller cells produce less insulin. Exact mechanisms are not clear.
Fat cells have been studied, where large and small cells have different genetic networks operating. When a fat cell is larger, the relation to extra cellular matrix changes through signaling pathways that change transcription factors. The matrix might produce more regulation for the larger cells. The large cells have very different metabolism and make different products and have more synthesis of lipids. These types of changes occur, also, in liver cells and red blood cells.

Large fat cells have different responses to insulin, sugar and fatty acids. These differences show that there is an optimum size for function. Larger fat cells produce more diabetes.

Cancer cells, also, have different behavior with different sizes. Larger cells are more malignant and have more differences between cells including varied shapes. These differences are not based on the environment, but are determined by the individual cell.

How Do Cells Know What Size They Should Be?

Cells understand quite a bit about themselves and their environment. It is remarkable what individual cells can do by themselves. They can send and receive wireless signals with many different types of cells and act upon the information received. An individual cell can understand where it is in relation to the entire body of trillions of cells. An individual leukocyte can travel to an exact distant location through many unusual and often unpredictable situations and terrains, while changing shape and methods of travel. An individual neuron in the fetus can travel an enormous distance to an exact spot amidst billions of cells. In the adult, axons do the same. Cells know what types of cells they are supposed to become. And cells know exactly what size they should be.

Where is the direction for the actions of this individual cell among trillions? How can anyone not be impressed by the intelligence of individual cells? Does this vast cellular intelligence show that the cell is connected with a form of mind?


1. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3522064/
2. https://phys.org/news/2016-05-central-clock-cell-division.html
3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyclin
4. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cell_cycle_checkpoint
5. https://evolutionnews.org/2013/08/the_cells_surve/
6. https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(16)30210-0?_returnURL=https%3A%2F%2Flinkinghub.elsevier.com%2Fretrieve%2Fpii%2FS0092867416302100%3Fshowall%3Dtrue
7. http://jonlieffmd.com/blog/how-do-cells-know-what-size-they-should-be

View user profile http://elshamah.heavenforum.com

Back to top  Message [Page 1 of 1]

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum